Why Leonardo was a saboteur, Gutenberg went broke, and Florence was weird – Ada Palmer
Descripción del Episodio
Renaissance history is so much wilder and weirder than you would have expected. Very fun chatting with Ada Palmer (historian, novelist, and composer based at the University of Chicago).
Some especially fascinating things I learned from the conversation and her excellent book, Inventing the Renaissance:
Not only did Gutenberg go bankrupt in the 1450s (after inventing the printing press), but so did the bank that foreclosed on him, and so did his apprentices. This is because paper was still very expensive, and so you had to make this big upfront CAPEX decision to print a batch of 300 copies of a book - say the Bible. But he’s in a small landlocked German town where only priests are allowed to read the Bible - so he sells maybe 7 copies. It’s only when this technology ends up in Venice, where you can hand 10 copies to each of 30 ship captains going to 30 different cities, that it starts taking off.
Speaking of which, the printing revolution wasn’t just one single discrete event, just as the computer revolution has been this whole century of going from mainframes -> personal computers -> phones -> social media, each with different and accelerating social impact. Books came first, but they’re slow to print, and made in small batches. The real revolution is pamphlets - much faster, much harder to censor. Pamphlet runners are how you can have Luther’s 95 Theses go from Wittenberg to London in 17 days.
So much other wild stuff from this episode. For example, did you know that the largest and best-funded experimental laboratory in 17th century Europe was very likely the Roman one run by inquisitors? Ada jokes that the Inquisition accidentally invented peer review. The focus of the Inquisition is really misunderstood - it was obsessed with catching dangerous new heretics like Lutherans and Calvinists - it only executed one person for doing science.
And this leads Ada to make an observation that I think is really wise: the authorities and censors are always worried about the exact wrong things given 20/20 hindsight. When Inquisition raids an underground bookshop during the French Enlightenment, they don’t mind the Rousseau, Voltaire, and Encyclopédie, but they lose their minds about some Jansenist treatises about the technical nature of the Trinity.
More broadly, a lesson for me from this episode is that it’s just really hard to shape history in the specific way that you want to impact things. One of the most famous medieval scholars is this guy Petrarch. He survives the Black Death in the 1340s, watches his friends die to plague and bandits, and says: our leaders are selfish and terrible, we need to raise them on the Roman classics so they’ll act like Cicero. So Europe pours money into finding ancient manuscripts, building libraries, and educating princes on classical virtues. Those princes grow up and fight bigger, nastier wars than ever before with new deadlier technology. And this, combined with greater urbanization and endemic plague, results in European life expectancy decreasing from 35 in the medieval period to 18 during the Renaissance (the period which we in retrospect think of as a golden age but which many people living through it thought of as the continuation of the dark ages that had persisted since the fall of Rome).
Anyways, the libraries Petrarch inspires stick around, the printing press makes them accessible to everyone, and 200 years later a generation of medical students is reading Lucretius and asking “what if there are atoms and that’s how diseases work?” which eventually leads to germ theory, vaccines, and a cure for the Black Death (Ada has longer more involved explanation of how cosplaying the Romans results through a series of many steps to the scientific revolution). Petrarch wanted to produce philosopher-kings that shared his values. Instead he created a world that doesn’t share his values at all but can cure the disease that destroyed his.
Watch on YouTube; read the transcript.
Sponsors
* Jane Street is still waiting on someone to solve their backdoor puzzle… They’re accepting submissions until April 1st and have set aside $50,000 for the best attempts. Separately, applications are live for Jane Street’s summer ML internships in NY, London, and Hong Kong. Go check all of this out at janestreet.com/dwarkesh.
* Labelbox can help ensure your agents don’t need to rely on overspecified prompts. They tailor real-world scenarios to whatever domain you’re focused on, and they make sure the data you train on rewards real understanding, not just instruction-following. Learn more at labelbox.com/dwarkesh
* Mercury’s personal accounts let you add users, issue cards, and customize permissions. This is super useful for sharing finances with a partner, a roommate… or even an OpenClaw agent. And, if you’re already a Mercury Business user, your personal account is free! See terms and conditions below, and learn more at mercury.com/personal-banking
Eligible Mercury Business users who apply for and maintain a Mercury Personal account may have their Mercury Personal subscription fee waived provided they remain a user on an active Mercury Business account in good standing. Standard Mercury Platform Subscription fees will apply if they no longer meet eligibility requirements, including but not limited to no longer being associated with an eligible Mercury Business account, or if the program is modified or terminated. Mercury may modify or discontinue this offering at any time and will provide notice as required by law. See Subscription Terms for full details.
* To sponsor a future episode, visit dwarkesh.com/advertise.
Timestamps
(00:00:00) - How cosplaying Ancient Rome led to the Renaissance
(00:28:49) - How Florence’s weird republic worked
(00:38:13) - How the Medicis took over Florence
(00:58:12) - Why it was so hard for Gutenberg to make any money off the printing press
(01:17:34) - Why the industrial revolution didn’t happen in Italy
(01:23:02) - The Library of Alexandria isn’t where most ancient books were lost
(01:41:21) - The Inquisition accidentally invented peer review
Get full access to Dwarkesh Podcast at www.dwarkesh.com/subscribe
Episodios Recientes
Más podcasts de Sociedad y Cultura
Ver toda la categoría →
En Buen Pedo
By shows
<p>El podcast más fuera de contexto de internet, dos grandes amigos se juntan a platicar de la vida real de la forma menos objetiva posible. </p><br /><p>Anécdotas, crisis existenciales y memes vivientes, Bastian y Conder sin duda se convertirán en tus nuevos mejores amigos. Siempre en buen pedo!</p><hr /><p> Hosted on Acast. See <a target="_blank" href="https://acast.com/privacy">acast.com/privacy</a> for more information.</p>
Meditación para dormir
By shows
<p>✨Bienvenidos a Meditación para Dormir, un espacio dedicado a transformar tus noches en momentos de paz y descanso profundo. Nuestro podcast es un refugio para el alma, un lugar donde la serenidad se convierte en tu compañía y la tranquilidad te envuelve como una cálida manta, acompañándote hacia un sueño reparador.</p><br><p>Sabemos que el ritmo de la vida moderna puede ser abrumador, con tensiones que afectan tanto a tu salud como a tu bienestar mental. Por eso, aquí te ofrecemos herramientas valiosas para cuidar de tu salud mental y emocional. A través de meditaciones guiadas, historias reconfortantes, ejercicios de relajación y prácticas de mindfulness, queremos ayudarte a liberar el estrés, aliviar la ansiedad y abrazar la calma interior.</p><br><p>Cada episodio está diseñado para acompañarte en tu viaje hacia un sueño profundo y reparador. Imagina un lugar donde tus preocupaciones se disipan suavemente y las tensiones del día se desvanecen, dejando espacio para la paz mental. Con nuestro podcast, descubrirás que descansar no es solo una necesidad, sino un acto de amor propio y autoayuda que nutre cuerpo, mente y espíritu.</p><br><p>La meditación guiada te llevará a un estado de relajación profunda, ayudándote a desconectar de los pensamientos negativos y a cultivar una sensación de bienestar. La relajación no solo favorece el sueño, sino que también fortalece tu salud en general, mejorando tu equilibrio emocional y ayudándote a enfrentar los desafíos de cada día con energía renovada.</p><br><p>Mientras escuchas nuestras palabras y la música suave que las acompaña, te invitarán a imaginar paisajes serenos, cielos estrellados y brisas suaves que acarician tu piel. Cada historia y meditación está tejida con cuidado para brindarte consuelo y seguridad, permitiendo que tu mente se sumerja en un estado de profunda tranquilidad.</p><br><p>"Dormir no es solo cerrar los ojos; es abrir la puerta a un mundo de descanso y recuperación. Es el momento en que tu cuerpo se regenera y tu mente encuentra claridad."</p><br><p>En este espacio, queremos recordarte que mereces este descanso, que cuidarte a ti mismo es una prioridad y que cada noche es una nueva oportunidad para sanar y renovar tus fuerzas.</p><br><p>El sueño es la base de una buena salud mental, y nuestra misión es ayudarte a lograrlo. Con episodios pensados para todas las noches de la semana, encontrarás contenido que se adapta a tus necesidades: meditaciones para calmar la ansiedad, relatos que inspiran reflexión, técnicas de relajación para aquietar una mente agitada y ejercicios de mindfulness para centrar tu atención y disfrutar del presente. </p><br><p>Haz de este podcast un ritual nocturno, tu momento de desconexión del mundo exterior y reconexión contigo mismo. Deja que nuestras palabras sean como una suave melodía que te envuelve y te recuerda que mereces este instante de paz. Te acompañamos con la certeza de que, mientras te permites descansar, también te permites crecer y sanar.</p><br><p>En este espacio, no estás solo. Estás rodeado de una comunidad que valora el bienestar y la tranquilidad tanto como tú. Permítenos guiarte hacia noches más calmadas y mañanas llenas de energía renovada. La calma te espera, todo lo que necesitas hacer es escuchar y dejarte llevar.</p><br><p>Respira profundamente, cierra los ojos y sumérgete en este oasis de paz. Este es tu momento, tu refugio, tu camino hacia un sueño profundo y una vida más equilibrada. </p><br><p>Bienvenido a este viaje hacia la serenidad, donde cada noche es una oportunidad para encontrar la paz interior que tanto mereces . ✨</p><hr><p style='color:grey; font-size:0.75em;'> Hosted on Acast. See <a style='color:grey;' target='_blank' rel='noopener noreferrer' href='https://acast.com/privacy'>acast.com/privacy</a> for more information.</p>
Verano en la SER
By shows
Estés en la playa, en la montaña, en el pueblo o trabajando, SER Podcast te acompaña y hace mejor tu verano.
Tú, hipócrita lector
By shows
Una conversación profunda entre lectores… con destacadas personalidades y escritores del país sobre su afición por los libros y las letras. Cada semana Cristián Warnken nos invita a sumergirnos en el placer que nos entrega leer, en un podcast que viaja por los diferentes mundos que abre la literatura y conversa con el hipócrita lector que todos llevamos dentro.
Habits and Hustle
By shows
Habits and Hustle helps share the stories, habits, and rituals of people's journeys on living fulfilled lives. Host Jennifer Cohen interviews thought leaders, entrepreneurs, and overall extraordinary people who share their insight and open up about the normally hidden aspects that have made a difference in their success.
Casefile True Crime
By shows
Fact is scarier than fiction. Subscribe to Casefile Premium to receive ad-free episodes released one week early, along with access to bonus Q&A’s, our exclusive show ‘Behind the Files’, and more.<hr><p style='color:grey; font-size:0.75em;'> Hosted on Acast. See <a style='color:grey;' target='_blank' rel='noopener noreferrer' href='https://acast.com/privacy'>acast.com/privacy</a> for more information.</p>
Hecho en Chile Podcast
By shows
Felipe y Nicolás te cuentan el chisme de las grandes empresas de Chile. Fundadores que lo apostaron todo, familias que se pelearon por la herencia, fraudes, fusiones y los escándalos que las marcas que usas todos los días preferirían que no contaras. Con datos reales y mucho, mucho humor. El chisme empresarial más serio de Chile.
Hágale como quiera
By shows
José Rodríguez, Juan de Ávila y César Daniel te darán consejos sobre tecnología y resolverán tus dudas legales que te facilitarán tu vida. Escúchalos todos los miércoles.